Same-Sex Marriage & Couples: Indian Style
Modern India advocates a multipolar world order and aspires to the UN Security Council membership. It makes a constructive contribution to solving pressing problems that the world community has had to face. Moreover, it respects international law principles, calling for effective measures to create security for all countries. Today, the Indian government is ready to be flexible to meet the ever-changing world.
Thus, child marriage has already been banned, women’s rights to education and work are recognized, there is significant progress in favor of gambling legalization, etc. Fortunately, the government realized that avowal of certain obvious facts would bring multiple benefits to the state. For example, thousands of $2 deposit online casinos and poker/lotteries/bingo/sports betting sites have already entered the IN gambling market. So, if it has been legalized, the state could benefit with $100+ billion. However, despite the trend toward legalizing same-sex marriage, India has still made no clear decision on this issue.
IN Same-Sex Marriage Legalization Is Impossible!
In 2023, India's Supreme Court refused to legalize same-sex marriage but said the rights of LGBTQ+ people must be respected. So, 5 judges of the Supreme Court concluded that such a decision is the prerogative of parliament as the main legislative body of the country. They considered that making changes to the current Marriage Law was beyond their competence. In India, 1.5%+ of the population (21+ million people), speak about their belonging to LGBTQ+. In reality, their number may be even higher. The Indian government has opposed such legislative changes, finding them as not comparable to the concept of the Indian family consisting of husband, wife, and children.
Dhananjaya Yeshwant Chandrachud (Chief Justice) said that there is no universal marriage concept. He also clarified that the adoption of laws recognizing and regulating homosexual marriages is within the competence of Parliament and state legislatures. According to him, marriage has gained importance as a legal institution largely because it is regulated by the state and provides several material benefits. So, the court cannot decide on this institution, as the IN Constitution does not stipulate the inalienable right of every citizen to marry.
The second most senior judge of the Supreme Court, Sanjay Kishan Kaul, noted that although same-sex relationships have been recognized in India since ancient times, only heterosexual unions have received legal support. He also noted that although the court cannot grant members of the LGBTQ+ community the right to marry, it has the right to make recommendations to the government. In particular, it is about the need to protect same-sex couples.
Reaction to the Supreme Court's decision was mixed. Those who would be directly affected by such changes were, of course, disappointed. All those who identify as sexual minorities hope that the government will take the necessary steps to end the discrimination that LGBTQ+ people face.
Many gay rights activists hoped that at least civil unions between same-sex couples would be considered legal. However, the Supreme Court denied them this right as well. Besides, the court did not permit same-sex couples to adopt children. Dr. Adish C Aggarwala (President, Supreme Court Bar Association) has expressed the opinion that allowing same-sex marriage is a bad idea. He believes that they hardly correspond to the Indian way of life and traditions.
The judges also commented on the marriage of transgender people. Essentially, they affirmed the supremacy of Indian law that marriage should and can only be between men and women. The Supreme Court has clarified that transgender people in India already have the legal right to marry - provided they marry a person of the opposite sex.
Still, The Court Gave Some Recommendations…
Dhananjaya Yeshwant Chandrachud offered a list of recommendations to the government. It turned out to be quite long:
- Ensure that the queer community is not discriminated against based on gender identity or sexual orientation.
- Take some measures to ensure that the LGBTQ+ community is not discriminated against in accessing goods and services available to society.
- To increase public awareness of LGBTQ+ identities.
- Establish a dedicated service that LGBTQ+ people can call if they experience any form of harassment or violence.
- Create and publish information about the availability of shelters in all counties for the LGBTQ+ community.
- Ensure that treatment intended to change gender identity or sexual orientation is discontinued.
According to the judges, the police should also take some measures to protect sexual minorities. In particular, it should not allow the oppression of same-sex couples and forcefully return them to their families if they do not want this. Also, if queer people complain to the police about domestic harassment, they must verify the validity of the claims and ensure their personal freedom and safety.
So, What's Next For The LGBTQ+ Community In India?
It is difficult to make any predictions. India stopped criminalizing homosexuality in 2018. Despite this, there are often cases where homosexual couples and transgender people are subjected to physical, moral, and emotional violence, including their families and neighbors. Every year in India and Pakistan, 5,000+ members of sexual minorities are killed. Rejection from family/society and severe physical violence drive some LGBT+ people to suicide. The passage of relevant laws and the Supreme Court recommendations are certainly important. However, it is also essential to change the mood in society so that queer people become its part.
