What online dating teaches us about being seen before being known

In a survey of American adults back in 2017, around 39% of heterosexual couples who met that year had met online - this is compared to 65% for same-sex couples. The stark difference is, in part, down to smaller communities, and sometimes marginalized communities, having more success online relative to traditional methods. When you’re outnumbered, online is a more efficient way to meet.
Today, most couples of all sexualities and identities meet online. For nearly all of them, their profile did some of the introducing, but what the research says about the order that follows is less obvious.
Text lets you set the pace
In Liesel Sharabi and John Caughlin's study, 186 online daters were surveyed before a first date (and 94 again after it). Respondents spent an average of 21 days interacting online before meeting in person. That is three weeks in which the only self on show is the one being typed, which can be seen as good or bad. Some see it as vetting, some see it as delaying meeting “for real”.
It fits the advice aimed at introverts, which is to emphasize pacing what you disclose. Text is where disclosure is easiest to ration, partly because you have breathing space to think before you speak. Rationing is only half of it though. What predicted a good first date (same study) was feeling similar to the other person, saying so, and the amount of information sought from them. In other words, it rewards asking as much as it rewards holding back.
Some services put the face first
The order can also be inverted. We can learn a lot from services built around adult video chat that lead with the camera rather than a profile - it throws people in the deep end to test if they’re compatible.
In Susan Sprecher's 2014 experiment, 184 university students (mostly young women) were paired with strangers for a two-part get-acquainted session. After the first interaction, pairs who had begun in text liked each other less than pairs who had begun in video, audio or face to face.
But when every pair then held a video conversation over Skype, the text starters still managed to catch up. So, it’s not a hard rule, and it likely comes down to personality types. When introverts are thrown in a room together, conversation can be difficult, and not because they don’t share things in common. This can fizzle out relationships just through virtue of finding small talk difficult with strangers.
In 2026, we are beginning to stabilize into a world where there are choices. For online dating, our profile can be an efficient way of filtering out a lot of poor matches. Then, the texting phase is another filter. There will be some false negatives, but the alternative is to spend more time and money on dates that are essentially blind.
The key to success is to try a variety of methods, but to learn from the lessons that online dating has taught us: Knowing a little bit about the date beforehand can help with conversation starters and lower our nerves.
