If yelling worked, parenting would be easy, wouldn't it? We'd simply shout, "Do it!" and our kids would comply. But here's the truth: it doesn't work. I've told parents, "Look, if screaming at our kids was effective, I'd be out of business. You'd just be able to yell at your child and he'd change. Or you'd bring your child to my office, I'd shout at him and call him names for 45 minutes, and then he'd go home and be nice for a week."
When a parent tells me they're yelling to get their child's attention, I understand--I'm a father myself and I've worked with parents and kids all my life. Let's face it, it can be frustrating being a parent, and it can be frustrating being a child. Personally, I believe people end up screaming at their kids because they've simply run out of other ways to solve the problem. Instead, they rely on power to get the job done. And that works--as long as the other person is weaker than you. But realize that once your child learns to yell back, your shouting will have no effect. And make no mistake, those skills are harder for kids to unlearn than they are to learn.
In my opinion, no parent should get in a screaming match with their child; it gives kids too much power. It also does not help you with the problem at hand, whether it's getting your child to take out the trash, stop playing video games, or to come home on time. The other danger is that yelling turns you into your child's emotional equal. When you're out of control, they know it--and for the time you're in that fight with them, your authority is undermined.
The 3 Things Your Child Learns from Yelling:
Why Shouting Leads to Escalation--and Over-the-Top Consequences
I've talked with many parents who think: "If I yell at my child, he'll stop his inappropriate behavior. I'll overpower him." Parents simply want their kids to do what they ask, and sometimes yelling seems to be the most effective alternative. But here's the rub: it doesn't teach your child coping or problem solving skills. It doesn't get him to understand the relationship between responsibility and accountability. All it says is, "I'm bigger than you and I'm louder than you and you're going to do what I say." But after awhile, kids stop listening.
By the time a child is ten years old, you hear parents saying things like, "You're grounded for a month," in order to keep control, because shouting doesn't work anymore. In effect, they're just trying to get a bigger club every time there's a conflict to manage their child's behavior. With pre-teens and teens, a bigger club becomes inefficient and ineffective. At this age, your child is meeting other kids who see their parents as nuisances at best. As your child develops that kind of peer group, it's hard for you to get a bigger hammer-- because now your child has nothing to lose: his need to belong is being met by his peers, not by his family.
So again, many parents just resort to upping the ante. They often threaten to ground their child for long periods of time, as I mentioned. But who wants to ground their child for thirty days? That means you've got to live with them for thirty days, too. I used to tell parents, "You want to ground your 16-year-old for a month? What, do you hate yourself?" I said this in a joking manner, but it was my way of stating that long, drawn-out punishments don't work--for the child or the parent. These kinds of consequences are ineffective and often only succeed in getting your child to shut down emotionally. And they certainly do nothing to stop the yelling and arguing between you and your child.
5 Ways to Stop the Yelling in Your Home and Get Your Child to Listen to You
If you want your child to listen to you, I personally think you need a system in your home in which it becomes the child's responsibility to listen to you. Here are five things you can start doing right away to stop the yelling and screaming:
When you use structure in your home, you immediately have a way of de-personalizing requests. You can simply point to the schedule (and I recommend that you post it in a central location in your home, like the kitchen) and say, "3 p.m.--time to turn off electronics and do your chores." When kids have structure, they are far less likely to challenge every request you make. They may still moan and groan, but the focus has been taken off of you and placed on the structure you've set up.
Say this simply and matter-of-factly. Don't get into any deep discussions or spend a lot of time talking about it. I recommend that you keep it to two minutes. You don't want to process anything or get into emotions. You just want to say it, and then get on with your day.
That conversation is over for you, and this stops the fight immediately. Know that when you leave the room, all the power leaves the room with you; your child is left to yell at the empty walls. If your child has a tantrum anyway, that's not your concern--you do not have to engage with him or stay there and watch it.
Finally, remember that if you're a child living in an environment where parents yell a lot, then yelling is normal in that environment--and a normal kid will learn how to yell back. After all, it seems like the appropriate response. I always recommend that parents make the decision to not yell--and really work on it. Believe me, the screaming matches in your home will die a natural death once you stop engaging in them.